Make both quotes answer the same question
Begin with one reporting currency and one definition of the job. In this workbook, both fictional quotes cover the same monthly converted volume and the same number of outgoing payments. All fixed charges are entered in USD. No currency conversion is performed by the worksheet itself. These conditions matter: comparing a subscription in one currency with fees in another creates a meaningless subtotal unless you first apply and record an explicit conversion assumption.
A plan is not inherently better because its percentage is lower. The result depends on how much qualifying volume receives that rate, the number of payments, the plan charge and any costs excluded from the rate. Wise’s US pricing distinguishes sending and receiving costs. Bancoli’s pricing distinguishes membership, receiving and payout features. Those source categories motivate the comparison. None of the figures below are taken from either provider.
A small, fully worked base case
| Input | Quote A | Quote B |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly plan | USD 0 | USD 15 |
| Conversion cost | 0.50% | 0.20% |
| Fee per outgoing payment | USD 2 | USD 1 |
| Monthly converted volume | USD 10,000 | USD 10,000 |
| Outgoing payment count | 4 | 4 |
Quote A costs 0 + (10,000 × 0.005) + (4 × 2) = USD 58. Quote B costs 15 + (10,000 × 0.002) + (4 × 1) = USD 39. Under those inputs, B is USD 19 lower for the month. That result describes the model, not an executable price or a recommendation to buy a plan.
Before carrying the result into a decision, check that the percentage includes the costs you intend it to include. If it is an all-in conversion cost, do not add an exchange-rate markup a second time. If receiving, withdrawal, network or intermediary charges are outside the quote, list them separately. An unknown category should remain unknown rather than becoming zero.
Find the volume at which the answer changes
Let V be converted monthly USD volume and N be the number of payments. In the example, A = 0.005V + 2N and B = 15 + 0.002V + N. The difference A − B = 0.003V + N − 15. A positive result means B costs less. A negative result means A costs less. Both cost the same when 0.003V = 15 − N.
The threshold is not a universal monthly-volume target. At ten payments the same model reaches equality at about USD 1,666.67. At fifteen payments it reaches equality at zero volume because the fixed payment-fee difference already offsets the subscription. If payment count exceeds fifteen, B is lower at any non-negative volume under these fictional linear rates. A different fee schedule needs a different equation.
This algebra assumes the same payment count for both routes. If one route batches invoices and another charges per invoice, first establish whether that is an equivalent workflow. A cheaper batch may change recipient references, approval steps or settlement timing. Do not silently change the job merely to improve the number.
Stress-test the result with three months
| Monthly volume | Quote A | Quote B | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| USD 2,000 | USD 18 | USD 23 | A lower by USD 5 |
| USD 10,000 | USD 58 | USD 39 | B lower by USD 19 |
| USD 20,000 | USD 108 | USD 59 | B lower by USD 49 |
A business with variable income should compare a sequence of plausible months rather than multiply its best month by twelve. Suppose the illustrative business has six quiet months at USD 2,000 and six ordinary months at USD 10,000, with four payments in every month. A totals (6 × 18) + (6 × 58) = USD 456. B totals (6 × 23) + (6 × 39) = USD 372. B is USD 84 lower before other charges.
If using B requires a fictional one-time USD 120 migration cost, its first-year total becomes USD 492 and A remains USD 456. The apparent winner changes for that first year. In a year without that setup cost, the modeled difference could change again. Keep one-time and recurring amounts in separate columns so a person reviewing the decision can understand the time horizon.
Treat migration and staff time as explicit assumptions
At a constant USD 19 monthly difference, a USD 120 setup cost takes 120 ÷ 19 ≈ 6.32 months to recover in the simple model. That calculation assumes the difference remains constant, the new service continues to fit the business and no additional cost arises. It does not tell you when money becomes available or guarantee savings. If the monthly difference is zero or negative, this simple model has no positive payback period.
Staff time can be included, but it should not masquerade as a measured provider performance result. For example, assuming an extra 30 minutes of administration each month at USD 30 per hour adds USD 15 to the route. In the ordinary-month example, the modeled USD 19 benefit becomes USD 4 after that assumption. If the work is occasional rather than recurring, place it in the relevant month instead.
Document why an estimate is reasonable and who will check it. A short time log during a limited trial can replace a guess later. Keep the account change itself separate from the recurring process: updating customers once is different from manually matching each invoice every month.
Know when a linear model stops being useful
Included allowances, minimum fees and volume tiers create bends in the cost curve. A single percentage cannot reproduce them faithfully over every volume. For a plan with an included allowance, separate eligible volume inside the allowance from excess volume. For a minimum fee, calculate both the percentage charge and the minimum, then apply the actual contractual rule. Do not invent a rule where the provider documentation is unclear.
Payment classification matters too. A local transfer, an international transfer and a conversion may be separate billable events. Some routes bundle them. A quote may expire before an approval arrives, and a recipient bank may add a deduction outside the original price. A useful comparison names these limitations beside the result rather than burying them in a generic disclaimer.
Use a range when an important cost cannot be fixed. If a downstream deduction might be between USD 0 and USD 25 per month, add both bounds to the same case. A USD 19 headline difference is not robust to that range. The right next action is to resolve the unknown, not announce a winner from the lower-bound case.
Write a decision someone else can reproduce
A concise record should identify the route, entity, plan, quote time, input currency, monthly volume, payment count and cost categories. Follow with the calculation, exclusions and the condition that changes the result. For our base case, that condition is converted volume falling below roughly USD 3,666.67 while four payments and the fictional linear rates stay unchanged.
Finish with a bounded decision: retain the current setup, investigate an unknown charge or trial one supported route while keeping the existing account. Eligibility and the ability to complete the payment remain prerequisites. A favorable spreadsheet does not override them. Read the payment operations workbook to compare the observed result with the original quote.
Download the worked break-even reference (CSV). You can also enter complete route costs in the local calculator. Its low and high cases vary volume only, so adjust fixed charges yourself when counts or plan tiers change.
Sources and scope
Official pages reviewed November 11, 2026. Product availability and terms can change. Worked amounts are illustrative unless explicitly attributed. This is not a hands-on account test.